Online Environment

Search Tools

Applied Searching

Site Evaluation

Site Submission

Home

Unit 2: Search Tools

Types-Search Engines

Overview Types and Comparison Assignment Reading Resources

 

     How many types of search engines exist?

Single Search Engines
Meta Search Engines
Subject Search Engines

           

 

                                             Single Search Engines

Examples
AlltheWeb    http://www.alltheweb.com/
Alta Vista http://www.altavista.com
Backflip http://www.backflip.com
Excite http://www.excite.com
Google http://www.google.com
HotBot http://www.hotbot.com
Lycos http://www.lycos.com
MSN.com  http://search.msn.com
Oingo.com  http://www.oingo.com
Teoma.com http://teoma.com
Togglebot.com http://www.togglebot.com
Wisenut  http://www.wisenut.com/

Background
In spite of claims of biggest, recent studies Nature 1999 revealed that only about 15% - 30% of the 800 billion web sites are actually retrieved. The web is developing at such a fast rate that the search engines are unable to keep  pace. For this reason alone, users are strongly encouraged to run a search in at least two large engines and check the top results for "comprehensive" results.

Trends
Faster,  bigger, simpler, and more meaningful summarizes the direction of search tools today. Today, Google  recently (September 2001) claimed 1 billion pages, followed by   AllthWeb (539 million pages), MSN Search (480 million pages),  Alta Vista (423 million pages),  and Northern Light (368 million pages) Google takes the prize for  biggest, but these results change quite frequently.  Search engines have evolved from the basic search results returned in ranked order to offering users additional ways to enhance search results  and ask questions. 

All search engines offer a box to enter terms for a basic search. To achieve the most precise results and glimpse any special services a search tool offers be sure to check out the Advanced Search option. Most web searchers never see the advanced search because when they type in terms they always get something, but effective searchers ask -- is it the best and most relevant information I could find and they use the advanced search option.

Search Us, Says Google. (interview with Sergey Brin & Larry Page) Technology Review. Nov. 2000

.

How a search engine works. Elizabeth Liddy. Searcher. May 2001 Proxy required

Darwin on the Web: Evolution of Search Tools

           Dale Vidmar   Computers in Libraries, May 1999 Proxy required

Future Revisited: What's New with Web Search
http://www.onlineinc.com/onlinemag/OL2000/sherman5.html
           Chris Sherman     Online May 20000  

Web Search Engines Evolve to Meet Challenges
           Karen Diaz  Reference & User Services Quarterly, Spring 1999
  Proxy required

<top of page>

 

                                         MetaSearch Engines

Examples
Ask Jeeves http://www.aj.com
Beaucoup http://www.beaucoup.com/
Dog Pile http://www.dogpile.com
IxQuick  http://www.ixquick.com/
Mamma http://www.mamma.com
Meta Crawler http://www.metacrawler.com
Search.com  http://www.search.com/
Vivisimo
http://vivisimo.com/

Background
Metasearch, megasearch, parallel or multiple search engines lay claim to providing the searcher with the best results from simultaneous searching in several search engines. They are made up of three parts: 1)dispatch mechanism which chooses the search engines in which to search, 2) interface agent which translates the search terms for each search engine to be searched, and 3) display mechanism which lists the results from the searches.

Search considerations
Usually metasearch tools don't take advantage of a search engine's  advanced search features and  retrieve only the top 10 - 25  sites from each search tool. In addition, they are subject to time outs which also limits results. They are used most effectively when search terms are unique and specific.

Vivisimo, founded in June 2000,  hopes to change some of our previous notions about metasearch tools by emphasizing "the knowledge that human users hope to find rather than the mathematical elegance of the algorithms". Vivisimo organizes results down the left side of the screen similar to Northern Light's custom blue folders. Ixquick another new entry into metasearching claims to be "the world's most powerful metasearch engine" by being fast and smart, returning the most relevant results in a comprehensive, clear, customizable manner. They offer 10 reasons why they are the best.

Searchers should consider the following in selecting a  metasearch tool:

  • what search engines are included in the search; can you select or deselect search engines?

  • how are search terms and syntax determined for each engine; is there a default search  or are terms translated appropriately?

  • evaluate  how results are displayed; are the best results listed on the first page or is scrolling required ?

Trends
Meta-Search Engines - U. California Berkeley 
http://www.lib.berkeley.edu/TeachingLib/Guides/Internet/MetaSearch.html

Surviving the Storm: Using Metasearch Engines Effectively
      Judi Repman; Randal D. Carlson  Computers in Libraries, May 1999
      Proxy required

<top of page>

 

                                             Subject Search Engines

Examples
Amazing Picture Machine   
Deja.com
        
Find Law
        
SearchIQ

Trends
Specialized Search Engines: Alternatives to the Big Guys   
       David King. Online, May 2000 Proxy required

Specialty Search Engines   http://searchenginewatch.com/facts/speciality.html
      Search Engine Watch, Danny Sullivan

 

<top of page>

 

 

 

      For information contact jegan@nvcc.edu
      Last revision August 24, 2002