COBRA Substandard Care Act 1986


Government addresses quality of healthcare

A series of legislative actions in the 1980s addressed quality issues in healthcare.  Initially in 1985 the Consolidated Omnibus Budget Reconciliation Act (COBRA) gave the government authority to deny payment for services that it considered "substandard."  The Professional Review Organizations (PROs) in every state were authorized to review care and deny Medicare payment to healthcare providers (both to hospitals and physicians) who did not meet the government quality expectations.  These reviews and subsequent denials became known as "quality denials." 

The initial legislation in 1985 mandated that the PROs do both pre-admission reviews (to determine the necessity of hospitalization) and also pre-procedure reviews of specific surgical operations.  Many in the healthcare field felt this expansion of PRO responsibilities symbolized expansion of "Big Brother" into the healthcare industry. 

COBRA 1985 is P.L. 99-272.  

   
Big Brother Looks Beyond the Hospital Care Setting

Additional major legislation was passed in 1986.  This is P.L. 99-509.  The new law expanded PRO review responsibilities for substandard care beyond the inpatient hospital setting.  Now the government, through the PROs, began looking at quality of care issues in the following settings:
  • Ambulatory surgical centers (ASCs)
  • Skilled nursing facilities (SNFs)
  • Home health agencies (HHAs)
  • Both inpatient and outpatient care from Medicare risk-contract health maintenance organizations (HMOs)

With the passage of this legislation, the peer review organizations are now required to report their findings of substandard care to licensing and certification agencies.

   
Today's focus on quality

 

During recent years, attention of the government in monitoring quality of care issues is focusing on outcome measurement.  With powerful computer systems and data mining techniques, government agencies are now regularly looking at quality and outcome issues.  They are monitoring both clinicians and organizations providing healthcare services and supplies.  Some groups are looking at global safety issues while others are addressing precise topics like medication management.  Since the government now pays almost half of the US healthcare costs, should they be functioning in the role of "Big Brother"?   
 
- Federal agencies
- State agencies
- Key legislation

*

Federal Civil False Claims Act - 1865
* Social Security Act - 1935
* Hill Burton Act - 1946
* Community Health Services and Facilities Act - 1961
* Public Law 89-97 (Medicare/Medicaid) - 1965
* OSHA - 1970
* TEFRA (PPS) - 1982
* COBRA (Antidumping) - 1985
* COBRA (Substandard Care) - 1986
* Health Care Quality Improvement Act (NPDB) - 1986
* Nursing Home Reform Act - 1987
* COBRA (quality/ cost/ effectiveness) - 1989
* Patient Self Determination Act - 1990
* Health Insurance Portability and Accountability Act - 1996
Regulatory mechanisms
Discussion questions
Syllabus
Library
Hays home page HIT home page Center home page NVCC home page

Send Email to bhays@nvcc.edu
Last revised: April 2003
© 2003 Barbara C. Hays