On the eve of an epic
battle for the solar system between an Earth armada and an alien Outsider
fleet the human Carson is designated by a superior entity to represent Earth
agains an Outsider in a duel of champions to settle which race will survive.
Background
Data
This
story was televised as "Arena," an episode of Star
Trek, the original series.
Navigation
Guide
Characterize
Carson.
Characterize
the Outsider.
Compare the combatants. Are they evenly matched?
Is
it fair to cause a war to be decided based on the outcome of a fight between
two individuals?
Is
it fair to destroy an entire fleet because an individual loses a fight?
What
right does the superior entity have to intervene between these two warring
fleets?
Further
Exploration
The
superior entity obviously must have other means by which to deal with these
warring fleets. What other actions could this entity have taken to stop
the war?
Watch
the "Arena" episode of classic Star
Trek. How has the story been altered? Why has the story been
altered in this particular way?
Note
that this story was written at the height of World War II. What connections
do you see between this story and current events of the time?