Teachability Checklist
The 2002 Dogwood participants originally developed this peer review teachability checklist, which has been modified by subsequent project participants.  While you should consider all of these content and teachability elements when you review a web site, not all of them may be relevant for each web site.
Use the following Teachability Checklist to complete peer reviews that focus primarily on content and teaching issues.
 

Site Overview

  • The home page clearly states the purpose of the site.
  • The primary and secondary audiences for the site are clearly indicated.
  • The content is sufficient to serve the purpose of the site.
  • The content is suitable for the intended audience.
  • The site has an obvious organizational structure, for example, a site map, table of contents, or main menu.
 

Quality of Content

  • Guidelines for audience use are clearly stated.
  • Content has a clear functional relationship to the purpose of the site.
  • Content is clearly organized for a hypertext environment; that is, content is chunked and non-linear and users can navigate freely and clearly through it.
  • Content is engaging.
  • Content is current.
 

Potential Effectiveness as a Teaching-Learning Tool

  • Pedagogy is sound.
  • The site is portable; that is, the site provides sufficient context so that other faculty and/or students can use it.
  • Site explicitly or implicitly identifies learning objectives.
  • Site contains real world and/or concrete examples and/or applications, if relevant.
  • Site language level is appropriate for the intended audience and either avoids jargon or defines it.
  • Site includes clear instructions for any activity.
  • Site contains or lends itself to concrete assessment as appropriate.
  • Site incorporates more than one learning style.
 

Audience Awareness Issues

  • Site contains information about what technical capabilities and materials the audience needs to use the site.
  • Tone is not offensive, condescending, sexist, ageist, racist, etc.
  • Contents are printable.  Tables are not wider than 600 pixels.
  • Site is reasonably ADA compliant (avoid frames, use clear fonts, organize tables horizontally, use succinct and descriptive alt tags on images).

 

Dogwood logo.
 

This page is copyright © 2004, A. Taormina and C.T. Evans
For information contact cevans@nvcc.edu